Try searching Google for something like “best dentist near me,” “best HVAC company in [your city],” or “best Italian restaurant nearby.”
Now try asking Gemini a similar question.
Something interesting is happening. Instead of just looking through a list of websites, people are increasingly being presented with a short list of recommended businesses, sometimes with ratings, reviews, and explanations of why those businesses might be a good fit.
At Astra Marketing, we’re noticing this in real-world local searches: businesses with strong review counts and ratings are often prominent in the results and recommendations. That makes us pay even closer attention to reviews when we’re evaluating a client’s local visibility.
And here’s the part business owners should care about: reviews aren’t just there to convince someone after they find you. They can also help determine whether you get found in the first place. It’s important to recognize that user behavior has changed and most people want validation for their product or service before they contact or show up.
Reviews Have Always Mattered. AI Is Raising the Stakes.
Google has long said that its local results consider relevance, distance, and prominence. That last one includes signals such as how many reviews a business has. Google explicitly says that more reviews and positive ratings can help local rankings. (Google Business Profile Help)
What’s changing is how those businesses are presented to customers.
With Google AI Overviews, Gemini, and AI-powered local search experiences, someone can ask for the “best” option and get a much shorter set of businesses to consider. When that happens, missing the shortlist can mean missing the opportunity entirely.
There’s some research behind what we’re seeing, too. An August 2026 study of Google AI Mode local recommendations found that recommended businesses had a median of 595 Google reviews, compared with 269 for businesses in its comparison group that appeared in Maps but weren’t recommended. The research covered 50 local questions in 10 U.S. cities, so it’s an interesting signal, not a universal formula.
A separate November 2026 analysis published by Search Engine Land also found that higher ratings and review volume were associated with stronger visibility in AI recommendations, including Gemini.
One important distinction: Google hasn’t published a formula telling us exactly how much reviews count in Gemini or AI Overviews. Correlation doesn’t prove that an AI tool chose a business because it had more reviews. Relevance, location, business information, website content, and other sources still matter.
But would we ignore reviews when we’re trying to improve local visibility? Absolutely not.
It’s Not Just About Getting to Five Stars
Imagine you’re choosing between two local businesses. One has a 5.0 rating from eight customers. Another has a 4.8 rating from several hundred.
Which would you feel more comfortable calling?
There’s no universally correct answer, but the number of people behind a rating gives it context. Fresh reviews help, too. A great rating built years ago doesn’t tell the whole story about the experience customers are having today.
BrightLocal’s 2026 small business research found that 47% of surveyed small businesses had fewer than 20 Google reviews, while an equal share of consumers said they wouldn’t consider a business with that few. That’s a pretty significant gap between what businesses have and what customers expect.
It also helps to remember that reviews aren’t just numbers. People read them to figure out whether a business is reliable, responsive, fairly priced, or experienced with the service they need. Those details can show up in the information AI tools use to describe and compare businesses, depending on the platform and sources available.
What We’d Focus On Right Now
You don’t need a complicated new AI strategy to get started. We’d focus on getting the fundamentals right:
- Ask for reviews consistently. Build a simple, ongoing request into your customer follow-up process rather than trying to collect dozens all at once.
- Make it easy, but don’t lead the customer. Send a direct review link or QR code and invite honest feedback. Don’t ask for five stars, dictate what to write, or offer discounts or gifts in exchange.
- Pay attention to recent reviews. A steady flow of genuine feedback shows what the customer experience looks like now, not just a few years ago.
- Respond to reviews. Thank people who take the time to share their experiences, and address negative feedback professionally. You’re speaking to future customers as much as the reviewer.
- Keep your Google Business Profile accurate. Categories, services, hours, photos, and business details help Google understand when your business is relevant. Reviews don’t replace a complete profile.
- Don’t neglect your website and other trusted listings. AI recommendations can draw on business websites and third-party sources, not just Google reviews. Make sure your services, locations, and contact details are clear and consistent.
- Check how you’re showing up. Search the phrases your customers would use, including “best” and service-specific questions, across Google Search, Maps, and Gemini. Try different locations, compare competitors, and repeat over time. AI recommendations can vary, so don’t treat one result as a definitive ranking report.
Google’s review policies prohibit incentives, selectively requesting positive reviews, and pressuring customers to post. The goal is to collect real customer experiences, not manufacture a better-looking score.
The Bottom Line
For a long time, businesses treated reviews mainly as social proof: get someone to your listing or website, and the reviews help close the deal.
That’s still true. But now reviews may also play a part in getting your business onto the shortlist when someone asks an AI tool where they should go or who they should hire.
We’re not saying that the business with the most reviews automatically wins. It doesn’t. We’re saying that review quality, volume, and freshness deserve a bigger place in your local marketing strategy than an occasional reminder to ask customers for feedback.
If you’re putting time into SEO, your website, and paid advertising but barely paying attention to your reputation, that’s worth fixing. Your next customer may be asking Google or Gemini for a recommendation before they ever visit your site.

