If you’ve been watching your organic traffic take a hit over the past few months, you’re not alone. There’s been a lot of discussion about websites losing search traffic, Google’s recent updates, and what AI is doing to the way people find information.
And for businesses that spent years building their visibility through SEO, we get why this is frustrating. Some companies built a significant part of their business around organic search. Watching that traffic fall, especially when you’ve worked hard to earn it, isn’t a small thing.
But it also doesn’t mean all is lost.
We think it’s important to separate a few things: what Google actually changed, how people’s search behavior is changing, and whether the content on your website is still delivering something worth finding.
First, What Actually Changed in August and November?
Google has been busy this year. Two updates worth understanding are the August spam update and the November core update. They’re not the same kind of update, and it’s important not to lump them together.
August 2026: Google’s Spam Update
(What Google confirmed:)
- August 18–21: Google rolled out a spam update affecting Search results globally and across all languages.
- The focus was spam enforcement, not a general core ranking recalibration. Google regularly updates its systems for identifying content and practices that violate its spam policies.
- Google didn’t publicly identify one specific tactic targeted by this update. It’s not accurate to say it specifically penalized all AI-generated content.
Source: Google Search Status Dashboard, August 2026 spam update
November 2026: Google’s Core Update
(What Google confirmed as of November 13:)
- November 10: Google began a broad core update affecting Search results globally and across all languages.
- The goal is to better surface relevant, satisfying results. A core update reassesses how content is ranked overall; it isn’t necessarily a penalty against a particular website.
- It’s still rolling out. Google said the process may take up to two weeks, so it’s too early to assign a specific traffic loss to this update or draw final conclusions about its impact.
Sources: Google Search Status Dashboard and Search Engine Journal’s November 10 coverage
There was also a separate September spam update, so if your traffic dropped somewhere between August and November, the timing matters. A chart moving down isn’t proof that one particular update caused it.
Search Behavior Has Changed, Too
Here’s the bigger issue: even if your website hasn’t done anything wrong, people aren’t searching the way they used to.
Google is answering more questions directly through AI Overviews and AI Mode. People are also turning to ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and other AI tools to research products, understand services, and compare options. Sometimes they get what they need without visiting a website at all.
A Pew Research Center study found that people clicked a traditional search result in 8% of Google searches that showed an AI summary, compared with 15% when no AI summary appeared. That study doesn’t explain every site’s traffic decline, but it does show why rankings and clicks can tell very different stories.
So if you’re looking at organic traffic alone and seeing a big drop, we wouldn’t automatically assume your SEO has failed. We’d want to understand where the decline happened, which pages and search terms were affected, whether rankings changed, and what happened to actual inquiries or sales.
Google has even added separate AI search visibility reporting in Search Console, so we can start seeing more of the picture. Just remember that an AI search impression isn’t the same as a click, a lead, or a sale.
Garbage In, Garbage Out Still Applies
There’s another part of this conversation that some businesses need to hear.
For the past few years, it’s been incredibly easy to produce content at scale. Give an AI tool a few keywords, have it write a dozen articles, publish them, and move on to the next batch.
But what’s the actual value in that?
If you’re publishing the same bland, generic explanation that 100 other websites already have, why should Google prioritize it? Why would an AI search tool reference yours? And more importantly, why would a potential customer want to read it?
“Garbage in, garbage out applies to AI, too. If the content doesn’t offer anything new, provide useful insight, or add real value, why should anyone prioritize it?”
Sam Shantiyai, Founder of Astra Marketing
We’re not saying AI-written content is automatically bad. We use AI as part of our own process. It’s useful for research, organization, and helping us work through ideas. But it shouldn’t replace the expertise, judgment, or unique insight that makes the article worth reading in the first place.
Google’s own guidance on AI-generated content makes a similar distinction: using AI isn’t inherently the issue; producing lots of pages without adding real value can run afoul of its spam policies.
And this is exactly where we’re focusing our clients. Rather than asking how many articles we can produce, we’re asking: What does this business actually know? What are its customers trying to figure out? And what can we share that helps someone make a better decision?
We’ve seen it with clients in specialized industries. Educational articles built around real experience and specific customer questions have earned meaningful visibility in both traditional and AI-powered search. There are a lot of factors involved, of course, but quality and consistency are still things we’re willing to bet on.
Don’t Forget the SEO Fundamentals
All this talk about AI doesn’t mean technical SEO suddenly stopped mattering. Quite the opposite.
If your website is difficult to crawl, pages aren’t indexed properly, important information is buried, or your site is painfully slow on mobile, you’re making things harder than they need to be.
We still pay attention to the basics: page structure, internal links, descriptive titles, readable content, indexing, technical errors, and relevant structured data where it makes sense.
Google’s guidance for AI search features is pretty direct on this point. Its AI features build on existing Search systems, and the same foundational SEO practices still apply. There isn’t a separate magic checklist that replaces them.
What About llms.txt and Other AI Tricks?
You’ve probably seen the conversation about llms.txt, a file some people suggest adding to help AI systems understand a website.
We’re experimenting with it on some projects because it’s relatively simple to maintain, and we’re interested in where these standards might go. But let’s not pretend it’s a proven shortcut to AI visibility.
Google explicitly says it does not use llms.txt for Google Search or its AI search features. Other AI services may handle these files differently, but the benefits still aren’t established across the board. We’d put far more effort into making the actual website useful and accessible than worrying about a file that might not even be used. Source: Google Search Central’s AI optimization guidance
People are even experimenting with random things like cats.txt (yes, seriously), and some AI tools have retrieved or cited these files in tests. But that doesn’t prove the file format itself gives you an advantage. It may just mean an AI search tool found the file through ordinary web search. Source: The cats.txt experiment
So who really knows what’s going on out there? We’re interested enough to keep testing, but we’re not about to put this ahead of doing the fundamentals well.
Something Simple We’re Doing: Answer the Question Up Front
One change we’re making across new content, and going back to improve on older pages, is to get to the point faster.
If somebody visits a page with a specific question, why make them scroll through five paragraphs before giving them the answer?
We’re adding short, useful summaries near the top of pages where they make sense. Not some robotic, keyword-stuffed “AI overview,” and not a replacement for the full article. Just a clear answer or takeaway up front, followed by more detail for the people who want to dig deeper.
We also want the content to be easier to scan, better organized, and written in a way people can actually understand. If a video, visual, or example helps explain something better than another paragraph, we’ll use it.
That benefits the end user first. If it also makes the page easier for search systems to understand, even better. We shouldn’t confuse that with a guaranteed ranking trick.
So What Should You Do If Your Traffic Is Down?
Before you tear apart your website or rewrite every article, here’s where I’d start:
- Look at the timing. Compare the drop with confirmed Google updates, but remember that search behavior, seasonality, competition, and technical issues can also change your traffic. For November’s core update, wait until the rollout is complete before making sweeping conclusions.
- Go deeper than total traffic. In Search Console, check impressions, clicks, click-through rates, search terms, and your most affected pages. Are rankings actually falling, or are fewer people clicking?
- Check the fundamentals. Make sure important pages can be crawled and indexed, your site works well on mobile, and nothing technical is getting in the way.
- Be critical of your content. Does it genuinely answer the question? Does it add expertise, examples, or a point of view? Or is it mostly repeating what’s already out there?
- Measure what matters to the business. Look at qualified leads, calls, orders, and revenue alongside traffic. Losing visits hurts, but losing valuable customers is the bigger concern.
Google recommends waiting at least a full week after a core update finishes before comparing Search Console data with a period before the rollout. And if you do make content improvements, give them time. Not everything rebounds overnight. Source: Google’s core update guidance
Where We Go From Here
I understand why the traffic drops have so many businesses worried. When organic search has been a reliable source of customers, seeing it change can feel like the ground is moving under you.
But we don’t think the answer is to abandon SEO or chase every new AI optimization trick that comes along.
At Astra, we’re continuing to focus on the fundamentals while adapting how we create and present content. That means keeping sites technically sound, making information easier to understand, and working with our clients to bring out the experience and insight that makes their business different.
Because at the end of the day, whether someone is searching on Google or asking an AI tool for an answer, the goal should be the same: give them something accurate, useful, and worth their time.
There’s enough generic content out there already. Let’s not add to it.

