We asked our founder, Sam Shantiyai, a question we hear from business owners all the time: If you had to choose, would you invest in SEO or paid search first?
We’ll keep this one short.
βI normally say paid, but that’s because most clients want to see immediate results. Y’all just aren’t that patient anymore. π€£
SEO takes time. You need to understand which keywords matter to your business, figure out where you stand today, and build a plan. Even a basic SEO program covering technical fixes, website improvements, local SEO, and monthly content can be enough to start driving growth. But it’s going to take time.β
β Sam Shantiyai, Founder of Astra Marketing
Why Paid Search Usually Gets Our First Dollar
With paid search, you can get in front of people who are already looking for what you sell. You’re not waiting to earn a ranking for every important search term. You can launch a campaign, start gathering data, see what people respond to, and make adjustments.
That doesn’t mean you flip a switch and the sales start rolling in. The ads have to be relevant, the targeting has to make sense, the tracking needs to work, and your website has to give visitors a reason to take the next step.
But if a business needs leads or sales sooner rather than later, paid search usually gives us a more direct place to start.
For e-commerce, the argument gets even stronger. Between search intent, product targeting through Google Shopping, and the ability to track actual purchases, we can make decisions based on what people are buying, not just how many people visited the site. Of course, those sales still need to make financial sense after ad costs and margins.
So, Does That Mean You Can Skip SEO?
Absolutely not.
SEO helps people discover your business without paying for every click. It also gives you a chance to answer questions, explain what makes your products or services different, and build visibility over time. That content can support discovery through traditional search and AI-powered search experiences, too.
But SEO isn’t something we can promise will pay off next Tuesday. Google itself says some changes can take weeks or months to show an impact (Google Search Central).
That’s why our ideal answer is often both, with different jobs to do. Paid search helps us reach interested customers now, while SEO builds a stronger foundation for the months ahead. What we learn from paid campaigns can even help us identify which searches and customer questions deserve more attention in our SEO plan.
And if the website isn’t ready to convert visitors, we’d rather fix that first than pay to send people into a bad experience.
Which Comes First for Your Business?
It depends on your budget, how quickly you need results, what it costs to acquire a customer, and how competitive your market is. For some businesses, especially those with very limited budgets or a strong existing organic presence, starting with targeted SEO improvements makes more sense than buying expensive clicks.
But when a business is ready to generate demand and measure what turns into leads or sales, we usually start with paid search while building SEO alongside it.
This might be the marketing world’s version of the chicken-and-egg debate. At Astra, more often than not, we’re putting the paid media chicken first.
Just don’t forget to feed the SEO egg.

